Five friends made one promise: Say I was with you. Then one of their husbands turns up dead.
Twenty-three years ago, five college friends made a promise.
If any one of them ever needed an alibi, she only had to say four words:
Say I was with you.
No questions until morning.
For Sloane Mercer, the pact has always been a relic of their younger lives, born from one frightening night and preserved by decades of friendship. Until a reunion dinner ends with Mara Quinn acting strangely—and hours later, Sloane receives the message she hoped never to see.
Say I was with you.
Sloane answers yes.
Then Mara’s husband, Caleb, is found dead.
Mara is missing. The police are asking questions. And Sloane has already deleted the one message that could explain why she lied.
As investigators begin to pull apart the women’s movements that night, Sloane discovers she isn’t the only one keeping secrets. Each friend had a reason to fear Caleb. Each remembers their old promise differently. And someone has been carefully shaping the story they are all telling.
The deeper Sloane digs, the less certain she becomes about the women she has trusted for more than two decades—or about her own role in protecting them.
Because an alibi only works when everyone tells the same lie.
And one of them knows what really happened.